Worst Motor Oil Brands To Avoid With Their Best Alternatives in 2023

Motor oil is essential for the efficient running of your vehicle’s engine. Therefore, it is critical that you take your time while choosing an oil brand. Motor oil performs a variety of essential tasks in your vehicle.

In the long run, you will wind up spending much money on repairs and upkeep if you choose an inefficient motor oil brand. Using high-quality motor oil will help keep your car’s performance and wear at their optimum.

Your car’s engine and other internal parts will be damaged if you don’t correctly lubricate it, mainly if you use low-quality motor oil. That’s why you must know about the worst motor oil brands to avoid.

The 5 most prevalent offenders on the market are highlighted in this article to assist you in avoiding purchasing defective motor oil.


5 Worst Motor Oil Brands To Avoid

Using the wrong type of motor oil can have a devastating effect on your vehicle’s powertrain. It would be best if you only used them when you’re running low on oil and need a quick charge. 

As soon as the emergency is over, you should also have a second oil change. Here are the five worst motor oil brands, along with the most acceptable substitutes, as determined by the extensive study.

1. Amalie Xcel Motor Oil

One complaint compares Amalie oil to cancer for automobiles, alleging that it’s out-of-date and dangerously damages the vehicles it comes in contact with on the road.

Brandon Opalka filed a class-action lawsuit against Amalie AOC Ltd., alleging that the company’s XCEL motor oil products lack additives to safeguard automobiles and might cause “catastrophic engine failure.”

According to the XCEL motor oil class-action lawsuit, Amalie motor oil is so hazardous that the American Petroleum Institute has deemed it “obsolete.”

The Amalie XCEL oil class action complaint alleges that the American Petroleum Institute has designated some oils, including some Amalie motor oils, outdated and recommends users avoid using the goods in their car for the danger of damaging the engine beyond repair.

The corporation purposely advertises its motor oils as safe, according to Opalka, and encourages customers to use them in their vehicles despite the well-documented hazards.

As a result, we’re going to provide you with honest advice on how to avoid using this terrible motor oil.

Best Alternative Motor Oil Brand: Valvoline

Since 1866, Valvoline appears to be a well-known manufacturer of high-quality lubricants for industrial and commercial use.

Valvoline comes to rescue those who drive every day and require high-quality engine oil. There are a variety of alternatives from Valvoline that are designed to provide year-round coverage.

The company’s oils are available in various viscosities, including SAE 40, 30, and 10W-30. One of the best 5w30 oils for high mileage may be found from Valvoline.

The modern complete synthetic oil thwarts Sludge and other deposits, which has anti-wear additives and components.

Valvoline oil’s additives ensure a smooth ride even in the most challenging situations. This brand’s conventional oil has passed the API SN Plus test, making it reliable.


2. Bullseye Motor Oil

Engine oil from the Bullseye line is likewise a dud. That’s a flawed concept, and everyone agrees on it. Its users also compile reports.

Look at the label on one of these bottles, and you’ll see that it doesn’t match what’s inside. The oil in their cars is really thin.

Many customers are dissatisfied with the company that makes motor oil. Some folks might also rate Motor oil as doing nothing for your engine.

According to yet another review, this motor oil fails to meet even the most essential criteria for proper motor oil.

Modern autos have no requirement for using Bullseye motor oil. Their motor oil is too old and lacks the necessary additives to keep the engine from corroding and breaking down, making it unsafe to operate. As a result, you’ve been conditioned to avoid using this particular kind of engine oil.

Best Alternative Motor Oil Brand: Mobil

Transmission fluids, grease, gear lubricants, oil filters, and motor oils are just a few of the lubrication items available under this well-known brand name.

Learn about the SAE viscosity grade and select an oil suitable for your car. It’s that simple! This brand’s sophisticated lubricant formula has unique modern engines that keep them running smoothly.

The company continues to offer high-quality equipment that keeps engines safe. Mobil has a wide variety of possibilities; in essence, you can pick an engine oil that’s right for your car and your driving style.


3. Xpress Lube Pro

You’ll save money by skipping Xpress Lube Pro as well but if you’re an experienced driver, avoid this company. Because this manufacturer doesn’t grade their motor oil depending on its viscosity, it is an added plus.

The PQIA did an organometallic investigation and found abrasive elements in this motor oil (Petroleum Quality Institute of America).

Their engine oil is filled with contaminants, and as a result, it is performing at a subpar level. If you don’t want any problems or harm to your car, stay away from this kind of motor oil.

Xpress lube pro has a significant issue with fakeness. If a brand exaggerates its features by providing inaccurate information about its product, you’re not going to choose that brand over others.

Every aspect of this oil’s production is a failure. Because of its low viscosity and absence of engine-protecting chemicals, it does not fulfill any quality requirement. It is a direct threat to your vehicle’s health.

Best Alternative Motor Oil Brand: Castrol

This brand is well-known for offering high-quality motor oils that help engines last longer. The Castrol premium motor oil brand has been around since 1899 when it was founded.

The vital engine parts will operate smoothly as long as you have excellent lubrication potential. This particular brand’s motor oil performed admirably even under adverse conditions, reducing engine wear to an essential degree.

One important thing to keep in mind is that this brand’s oil is among the best in the business. In addition, Castrol oil helps keep your engine cleaner by preventing the buildup of Sludge, which may lead to problems like banging.


4. Quaker State Q

Quaker State Q should not be used if you want your car to run at its peak efficiency. Choosing Quaker State Q motor oil will allow you to rapidly and conveniently disperse the oil.

 It’s a sign of high volatility if your oil circulates swiftly and freely.

This oil’s extreme volatility and poor quality may be seen in its rapid diffusion. Because it’s so hefty, you’ll be unable to carry it in your pocket or in your beloved automobile, both of which will suffer a significant setback.

The reason for this is that their motor oil lacks the required lubrication and quality to keep your car running at its best.

This is not the case, however. You should avoid using this kind of motor oil if you don’t want it to harm your engine in the long term and instead hunt for alternatives that are true to their quality.

 Best Alternative Motor Oil Brand: Shell Engine Oil

This company has been delivering high-quality engine oil that has reduced the cost of engine maintenance. The cloak seems to be a 1907-founded energy firm with operations in more than 70 nations.

Certain additives also keep pollutants away from the engine, allowing it to run longer. Shell Helix 5W-40 API SN Ultra Synthetic oil is an excellent choice for gasoline and diesel cars since it’s an outstanding alternative for both fuel types.

This brand’s engine lubricants perform perfectly since they lubricate and cool the engine components. The low-emission recipe of the motor oil makes it environmentally beneficial.

Shell engine oil is designed to function well in all-weather situations, regardless of the temperature.


5. Q10-40 Motor Oil

This oil, too, is a huge problem and for the same reason as many of the other oils on our list, this one does not contain chemicals to safeguard your engine from wear and tear over time.

Poor quality oil may damage your engine over time because of its high viscosity, the essential component in determining how much drag a fluid imposes on moving parts.

Because of its shallow viscosity index, it gets much dirtier when exposed to high temperatures.

If you care about maintaining your vehicle with high-performance motor oils that won’t harm your engine, you should never buy Q10-40.

Best Alternative Brand: ACDelco

ACDelco looks to be a household name for high-quality vehicle components and lubricants. This American manufacturer is the primary supplier of Buick, Chevrolet, Cadillac, and GMC. Because of this, they are recognized for their high-quality goods, including fluids, oil, and other auto maintenance items.

Their motor oil is available in different viscosities to choose the best product for their needs. As a result, whether you have a low- or high-performance engine, ACDelco’s compatible engine oil may help it run better.

This brand’s engine oil is specially developed to fulfill the lubricating requirements of engines. As a result of modern additive technology, this brand’s motor oil consistently passes the most stringent industry requirements.

Related: Oil Filter Brands To Avoid With Best Alternatives


Things to Consider Before Purchasing Engine Oil for Your Car

In the market nowadays, there are various types of engine oil to choose from. Also, there are some worst motor oil brands to avoid. Evade is swayed by price when selecting the correct type of oil for your car.

When it comes to your automobile, you need to ask yourself a few critical questions and grasp the importance of the following:

Codes For Classifying Oil

While shopping for engine oil, be sure to look for the API certification logo on the oil bottle, which is also referred to as “Starburst.” The International Lubricant Standardization and Approval Committee (ILSAC), a collaborative effort of American and Japanese automotive manufacturers, has established a seal of approval for oil that fulfills your current engine’s protection level and fuel efficiency standards.

Conditions Of The Road

Drivers should consider the weather and road conditions they experience when driving, regardless of whether they reside in a hot or cold environment or travel on paved or unpaved roads.

Depending on the circumstances, your car may need to be serviced more frequently by changing your engine oil. When picking on motor oil, take your driving habits and the climate in your area.

Additives For Motor Oil

To keep your engine cool, clean, and corrosion-free, refiners add a variety of additives to the oil. As much as 25% of the cost of the oil can be attributed to these additives.

Ratings For Viscosity

The oil’s flow resistance or flow rate is called its viscosity. The viscosity of an oil is used to classify and categorize it. Multi-viscosity oil is one type of oil, whereas single-viscosity oil is another.

Multi-viscosity oil is intended to be used in nearly every automobile. It is easier to flow when the number is less than one. You can find an oil viscosity chart in your owner’s handbook to help you pick the proper viscosity for your car.


Different Types Of Motor Oil

Most vehicle repair specialists explain the many types of motor oil. Before thinking about the motor oil brands to avoid, this article will help you choose the best one for your vehicle.

Full-Synthetic Oil

It is possible to make synthetic engine oil in a factory or laboratory. When your materials are held to a higher standard, they are more consistent, making it easier to regulate the production process. As a result, these lubricants are of higher quality and better for your engine.

There is a price to pay for this, however—literally. Traditional motor oil is less costly than a full-synthetic product. A full-synthetic oil will add anywhere from $20 to $40 to the price of an oil change, depending on how much your vehicle requires.

It is also common for synthetic oils to last longer than conventional oils before they need to be replaced.


Oil Blended With Synthetic Components

Blended synthetic oils combine synthetic and natural components to create a new type of oil. To put it another way, it’s a combination of traditional and synthetic oils meant to maximize the advantages of each while minimizing their disadvantages.

In terms of protection and performance, synthetic oils are superior to traditional oils, although they aren’t nearly as excellent as full-synthetic oils. Compared to regular oils, they have a longer shelf life but not as long as fully synthetic ones.

Although they’re not by much, fully synthetic oil is more expensive than regular oil. Overall, they’re a good option for folks who want to keep prices down but need a bit extra assistance with their vehicle.


High-Performance Oil

high-mileage oil is a distinct subset of the broader oil industry. Unique compounds in these products assist in maintaining engine seals, which keep oil from evaporating and enhance performance.

When a car’s odometer reaches a certain number of miles, the need for further protection becomes critical since oil burn-off can lead to increased engine wear and a shorter lifetime. The use of high-mileage oil is strongly recommended if you drive your automobile more than 75,000 miles.


Conventional Oil

You’re probably familiar with conventional oil because it’s the oil in your car. Crude oil is extracted from the ground and processed at a plant to make this product. With the help of various additives, the oil’s viscosity (thickness) and engine-protective qualities are enhanced before being packaged for use in your vehicle. This is it.

As with anything, there are benefits and drawbacks. Because of this, the cost is the most crucial benefit. You may save money by using conventional oil to safeguard your engine and keep your automobile operating smoothly.

There are no substandard motor oils on the market anymore; as long as you purchase the appropriate weight and amount, you can anticipate its good performance. It’s also reasonably practical.

However, their drawbacks outweigh their advantages. This is because they’re made from more naturally occurring components. As a result, they also provide less protection than other varieties.


Symptoms Of Using The Wrong Type Of Oil In Your Car

 Here are some crucial symptoms on how you can determine the quality of your engine oil.

A Burning Oil Smell

If the oil’s hot viscosity isn’t high enough, it might degrade under scorching circumstances and fail to lubricate the engine’s components adequately. As a result of this, the oil will be combusted.

Excessive friction between metal components might cause long-term harm to your engine over time. You may also experience the burning smell of synthetic oil and leaking, as indicated before.

Cold Weather Makes It Difficult To Begin

Your automobile may not start in freezing weather if your oil’s cold viscosity is too high (the oil is too thick). In this instance, the oil is too viscous to lubricate all moving components effectively, producing extreme resistance while the car starts.

Ticking Engine In The Cold

You may hear a ticking noise in your engine if you use too little motor oil for the conditions. Most of the time, it will begin to quiet down after a few minutes of driving.

Using the wrong engine oil can lead to inadequate lubrication and coating of all engine parts. Consequently, this occurs. Metal parts like valves and valve lifters are slamming against one other, causing the sound you’re experiencing. Switching to a different oil viscosity for a short period may solve the issue.

Leakage Of Oil

A car with high mileage or an older engine may have tiny oil leaks if synthetic oil is used instead of traditional oil. This is related to how synthetic oils flow differently than regular oils. It’s easier for the oil to go into places where ordinary oil can’t.

There may be a burning smell, or oil drips on the garage floor when using synthetic in certain situations, but there is no guarantee that it will do any damage.

It is essential to keep an eye on your oil level because it is steadily seeping. On your following oil change, it’s a good idea to switch back to standard oil. Synthetic oils are not suitable for all cars.

Consuming Much Fuel

Using the wrong type of motor oil can have a negative impact on your gas mileage. This is because thicker oil makes moving parts, such as pistons, more challenging to move.

Even though your engine will be safeguarded, it will necessitate more frequent gas station visits. Oil of a thinner consistency (10w-30 instead of 20w-50) should alleviate the problem.


Is It OK To Use Two Different Types Of Oil In Your Car?

Whether or not you may combine various brands, classifications, and viscosities of automobile lubricants is a frequently asked issue on the internet. If you ever find yourself in a situation where you need to refuel your vehicle’s engine, this knowledge will come in handy.

The engine won’t be harmed by mixing auto oils, but a few things to keep in mind. Seals and bearings can be damaged if various hydraulic, compressor, and gearbox oil compositions are used. Certified oils are exempt from this rule.

A base and a set of additives constitute the oil base and the distinctive attributes of the particular engine oil. API oils are all meant to be compatible.

In the end, the physical qualities of the various oils produced by different oil makers may differ, but they are interchangeable if the API rules for manufacturing are followed to the letter.

Various companies will utilize variable anti-wear, anti-oxidant, and detergent combinations in their compositions, and different viscosities must also be considered.

So, to answer your question, even though the API says they are compatible, you should avoid mixing and topping up auto oils from various brands or manufacturers.


Other Well-Known Brands Of Motor Oil

Comma: This brand has a wide variety of motor oil products to maximize performance and reduce fuel consumption. This motor oil is a good choice for commercial and personal vehicles.

Halfords: Car components and accessories are widely available from this well-known manufacturer. Those in the United Kingdom should know that Halfords has one of the most effective alternatives for engine oil.

Liqui Moly: This brand has emerged as a well-known name in the lubricant and additives industry. Consider Liqui Moly, one of Germany’s most famous motor oil brands, to be among the best in the world.

Millers: Motorsport, agricultural, and automotive uses have relied on Millers’ oil since its founding in 1887. In the United Kingdom, it appears to be a top-tier motor oil brand. Full or semi-synthetic oils can be found in a wide variety.

Motul: The French firm Motul, which manufactures and distributes high-quality vehicle lubricants worldwide, is widely recognized as one of the greatest motor oil brands in Europe and beyond. They provide semi-synthetic and synthetic oils that offer good protection for your car.

Petronas: Since 1974, this Malaysian oil and gas firm has satisfied customers’ demands for a wide range of motor oils.

Ravenol: This brand looks well-known for its creative technology and is yet another great motor oil provider in the business. Consequently, you can rely on the engine oil Ravenol to keep it in good working order.


Differences In The Meaning Of API Symbols

Here are some of the API symbol and their meanings. You can learn about them from the below-mentioned symbols.

  • SN Plus- Lubricants Standards Group members agreed on November 9, 2017, to adopt SN PLUS, an additional classifier that may be used with API SN and API SN+. According to API, there were first SN PLUS licenses issued on May 1, 2018. To learn more, please visit this page.
  • SN- High-temperature deposit protection, more stringent sludge management, and seal compatibility were the primary goals of the October 2010 introduction of this product for 2011 and older cars.
  • SM- Current for automobile engines manufactured before 2010.
  • SL- Engines manufactured before 2004 are not considered current.
  • SJ- Engines manufactured before 2001 are considered out-of-date.
  • SH- Most gasoline-powered automobile engines developed after 1996 are not compatible with this product. Engine sludge, oxidation, and wear may not be adequately protected.
  • SG- Most gasoline-powered automobile engines produced after 1993 are ineligible for their usage. Engine sludge, oxidation, and wear may not be adequately protected.
  • SF- It is not recommended for use in most gasoline-powered automobile engines manufactured after 1988. Engine sludge buildup may not be adequately prevented.
  • SE– After 1979, gasoline engines developed for passenger cars and light trucks will not run on this additive.
  • SD– No longer compatible with gasoline-powered engines developed after the year 1971. Unsatisfactory performance or equipment damage may result if used in more modern machines.
  • SC- To be used in automotive engines developed after 1967 is not recommended. Unsatisfactory performance or equipment damage may result if used in more modern machines.
  • SB– No longer acceptable for use in gasoline-powered automobiles made from 1951. Using it in more modern engines might result in subpar performance or damage the engine itself.
  • SA- After 1930 gasoline-powered automotive engines are ineligible for the use of this additive. Using it in more modern engines might result in subpar performance or damage the engine itself.


People Also Ask

What Exactly Is Poor Motor Oil?

Depending on whether the oil is thin, old, or poorly textured, you may notice a difference in the sound every time you drive.

When driving with poor oil quality, your engine may generate a banging sound while the car is in motion, which may be annoying. Other noises, such as ticking, can be caused by oil difficulties, which we’ll examine in more detail in the next section.


Do The Brands Of Motor Oil Make A Difference?

There is no benefit to spending more on brand-name oil as long as the oil weight and certifications meet the requirements of your automobile. Blackstone Laboratories has analyzed the oil in hundreds of thousands of cars over its history.


Is There A Difference Between Different Brands Of Motor Oil?

There is no benefit to spending more on brand-name oil as long as the oil weight and certifications meet the requirements of your automobile.

As long as they fulfill your vehicle’s oil weight and certification requirements, all of them are interchangeable.


Is Valvoline A Better Alternative Than Pennzoil?

Because of its oxidant resistance and detergents, the Valvoline Advanced Full Synthetic minimizes the production of acids in engines, and it provides superior protection to engine seals than the Pennzoil Ultra-Premium, according to the manufacturer.


Is It Permissible To Use Entirely Synthetic Oil In Older Automobiles?

The simple answer is that synthetic oil may be used in older automobiles, recommended. However, firms have adjusted their compositions since then, and they now test their products for seal compatibility as part of their quality assurance process.


Is It Permissible To Combine Different Brands Of Motor Oil?

To answer your question, yes, you may safely combine one brand of oil (for example, Mobil 1) with a different brand (for example, AMSOIL) or conventional oil with synthetic oil (in fact, a synthetic blend is what you’re looking for). The majority of synthetics on the market are entirely compatible with traditional oils and may be safely combined.


Final Words

Our primary purpose was to safeguard you from the worst consequences of using a faulty motor oil brand. We make every effort to cover every aspect of all terrible motor oil brands and their alternatives. 

To accomplish this, a motor oil brand is required. As a result, you think about the worst motor oil brands to avoid strictly.

In conclusion, motor oil is critical in ensuring that your car remains in top operating condition. As a result, you must select high-quality motor oil to ensure that your vehicle remains in good working order.


More to read:

Leave a Comment